Sophia
Manchester United supporters are holding their breath, hoping the humiliating Carabao Cup second-round exit to Grimsby Town marks the absolute low point of the 2025-26 season. Under Ruben Amorim, whose beloved 3-4-2-1 system is still finding its footing, the Red Devils underwent a significant squad overhaul this summer, particularly bolstering an attack that struggled immensely last season, culminating in a dismal 15th-place Premier League finish and no Europa League silverware.
While the summer transfer window addressed some critical areas, it certainly didn’t plug every hole in Amorim’s ambitious project. As the dust settles, Sports Illustrated delves into what Manchester United’s strongest starting XI could look like with all players fit and firing, aiming to return the club to its former glory.
Amorim’s Vision: The 3-4-2-1 Blueprint
Amorim’s tactical predictability means that summer signings were meticulously chosen to thrive within his preferred 3-4-2-1 formation. The clear intent was to revolutionize an attack that, by historical standards, was woefully ineffective last season. Let’s break down the ideal lineup:
Goalkeeper: Senne Lammens – A New Face Between the Posts
Amorim’s lack of conviction in André Onana and the evident flaws of Altay Bayındır necessitated a move in the market. United secured the services of the relatively unknown Senne Lammens from Royal Antwerp for a modest fee. Early data suggests the Belgian could immediately stake his claim as the Red Devils’ number one.
When life gives you Lammens… 🇧🇪
Welcome to the club, Senne 🤝 pic.twitter.com/Abp9aWWrHd
— Manchester United (@ManUtd) September 1, 2025
Defence: A Blend of Youth, Experience, and Grit
Right Centre-Back: Leny Yoro – The Future Cornerstone
Leny Yoro, despite an early injury setback, has quickly proven his immense talent. The young Frenchman’s imposing presence, excellent timing, and recovery speed mark him as a potential linchpin in United’s defense for years to come, regardless of the system. His potential to be a cornerstone is undeniable.
Central Centre-Back: Matthijs de Ligt – A Revitalized Presence
While Harry Maguire remains an option, Amorim has favored Matthijs de Ligt at the heart of the back three. The Dutchman, perhaps not reaching the stratospheric heights predicted in his Ajax days, excels in this role, particularly when tasked with man-marking robust attackers. His physical prowess makes him a comfortable fit in the central defensive role.
Left Centre-Back: Lisandro Martínez – The Tenacious Argentine
A fully fit Lisandro Martínez is undoubtedly a key component of United’s best defensive setup. Despite ongoing debates about his height, the Argentine offers invaluable qualities in possession and a fiery determination to set the tone with his challenges. His return from injury will be crucial for defensive stability.
Midfield: Dynamic Wing-Backs and a Powerhouse Core
Right Wing-Back: Amad Diallo – A New Role, New Opportunities
Amad Diallo was a rare bright spot in the bleak 2024-25 campaign. With new attacking arrivals, his future under Amorim appears to be at right wing-back. Having performed the role effectively early in Amorim’s tenure, Amad’s dynamism and flair on the right flank could be pivotal this season. He brings a spark and a touch of magic that United desperately needs.
Central Midfield: Kobbie Mainoo – The Academy Gem
Kobbie Mainoo is arguably United’s most exciting academy graduate in a decade. Despite nearly leaving on loan for regular playing time ahead of the 2026 World Cup, Mainoo must be an integral part of this United team. His talent is undeniable, and Amorim must find a way for him to flourish in the midfield, even with defensive aspects needing refinement. For more insights on Mainoo’s journey, read about Kobbie Mainoo: From Man Utd’s FA Cup Final Hero to Benchwarmer.
Central Midfield: Casemiro – The Veteran Anchor
After a challenging 2023-24, Casemiro has shown renewed vigor under Amorim, benefiting from a reduced defensive workload. While he shouldn’t be a regular starter at this stage of his career, United’s failure to adequately bolster the engine room in the summer means his experience remains vital. He still possesses the footballing intelligence to dictate play.
Left Wing-Back: Patrick Dorgu – A Work in Progress
Patrick Dorgu, who joined in January, has had an indifferent start to his United career. While a full preseason with Amorim was expected to benefit him, his early performances in 2025-26 are inconclusive. However, given the lack of alternatives (Diogo Dalot is not a preferred option), Dorgu has the opportunity to make this wing-back role his own.
Attack: Unleashing the Firepower
Attacking Midfield: Bryan Mbeumo – The Efficient Operator
United eventually met Brentford’s demands for Bryan Mbeumo, and the Cameroonian has the makings of a star at Old Trafford. Coming off his best campaign to date, Mbeumo’s efficiency in front of goal and suitability for Amorim’s system make him a promising addition. His partnership with Amad down the right flank could be a key attacking threat.
Attacking Midfield: Bruno Fernandes – The Creative Maestro
United’s captain, Bruno Fernandes, presents a tactical conundrum for Amorim. His immense talent dictates he must be in the starting XI, but his optimal position in this system is debated. Playing him deeper offers more control but risks defensive vulnerability, while a more advanced role unleashes his creative freedom as a playmaker. Finding the right balance will be crucial for the team’s overall success.
Centre-Forward: Matheus Cunha – The False Nine Option
While the £74 million Benjamin Šeško is the long-term striker, his adaptation will take time. Matheus Cunha, United’s first major summer signing, offers a different dimension. Amorim has shown a willingness to deploy a false nine, and Cunha’s versatility and link-up play could be vital. While this frontline might lack a traditional penalty-box presence, the intricate combination play between the front three could be devastating once it clicks. Šeško is expected to become the main man once he settles, but for now, Cunha leads the line.
The Road Ahead
This envisioned XI represents a blend of new talent and established stars, all designed to operate within Ruben Amorim’s specific tactical framework. The jury remains out on whether this revamped squad can truly return Manchester United to the summit of English and European football. However, the intent to rejuvenate both ends of the pitch is clear, and supporters will be eager to see this potential dream team take shape on the Old Trafford turf.
Published Sep 10, 2025
JAMES CORMACK
James Cormack is a Sports Illustrated Soccer freelance writer with an avid interest in tactical and player analysis. As well as supporting Spurs religiously, he follows Italian and German football, taking particular interest in the work of Antonio Conte & Julian Nagelsmann.
